Whether a worker is an employee or a contractor decides who pays the holiday pay, sick leave, KiwiSaver and ACC levies. Getting it wrong is the most common first-hire mistake. This guide covers the test Employment NZ uses, which changed on 21 February 2026.
This guide is general information, not legal advice. For a borderline case, get advice from an employment lawyer or adviser. For the older, general comparison see contractor vs employee.
The test has two steps
Employment NZ's page on employee or contractor sets out a two-step test. The first step, the gateway test, has been in force since 21 February 2026 and is not retrospective.
Step 1: the gateway test
A worker is a contractor only if all five of these apply:
- The written agreement says they are an independent contractor, or not an employee.
- They may work for others, but not at the same time as they work for you.
- They can choose when to work, or can subcontract the work.
- They can decline extra work without ending the arrangement.
- They had a reasonable chance to get independent advice before signing.
If any one is missing, the worker is not a contractor under the gateway test and the common law test applies.
How the five read for a tradie
This is our reading, not Employment NZ's. A labourer who turns up when you tell them, on your site hours, and who cannot send someone else in their place will usually fail criterion 3. A subbie who quotes a job, sets their own days, brings a team and takes other work between your jobs is closer to meeting all five. Criterion 1 matters on its own: a contract headed independent contractor does nothing if the other four are not met.
Join the mailing list
Step 2: the common law test
When the gateway test is not met, the common law test looks at the real relationship. Employment NZ lists four areas:
- the intention of the parties
- control compared with independence
- how far the worker is integrated into the business
- the fundamental or economic reality, meaning whether the person is in business on their own account
Employment NZ lists these signs of a contractor: they own their tools, are paid by results, pay their own tax, GST and ACC, can make a profit or loss, can hire others and carry risk, and have multiple clients.
What IRD says
IRD's page on whether you are an employer puts it plainly: if you decide when, where and how people do their work, you are an employer paying salary or wages.
What is at stake
Employment NZ says contractors fall outside the Employment Relations Act, but health and safety laws apply to both employees and contractors. If you treat an employee as a contractor you risk:
- missed annual holidays, sick leave and KiwiSaver
- the wrong tax and ACC levies being paid
Free terms-of-trade template
A ready-to-paste terms-of-trade template for your invoices and quotes, so you can charge interest on late payers.
Our ACC for employers guide shows how levies differ. Employers are invoiced on their payroll. A contractor who is a sole trader pays their own levies, covered in ACC for self-employed.
A practical checklist before you sign anyone
- Write down who decides the hours, the methods and the materials.
- Check each of the five gateway criteria one by one, and keep a note of the answer.
- If you want a contractor, give them time and a real chance to get independent advice before they sign.
- Check the signs on Employment NZ's contractor list: their own tools, other clients, paying their own tax, GST and ACC, and carrying their own risk.
- If most answers point to employee, hire them as one. Then follow hiring your first employee.
If you are weighing up your own structure as the one hiring, see sole trader vs company.
Health and safety does not depend on the label
Employment NZ's page says health and safety laws apply to both employees and contractors. WorkSafe's primary duty of care page says a business or undertaking must look after its workers and any other workers it influences or directs. Calling someone a contractor does not remove that duty.
Moving from contractor to employee
If a worker was a contractor and becomes an employee, treat it as a new hire. IRD wants you registered as an employer as soon as you start employing staff, and Employment NZ requires a written agreement signed before work starts. A trial period is only for an employee who has not worked for you before, so a person who already worked for you as a contractor may not qualify. Check the trial periods page before you plan on one.
Sources
- Employment NZ: Employee or contractor?
- Employment NZ: Trial periods
- Employment NZ: Hiring your first employee
- Inland Revenue: Work out if you are an employer
- WorkSafe: Primary duty of care
Employment NZ, IRD and WorkSafe pages were read on 2 November 2026.